Did Mitt Commit Voter Fraud? Town Clerk Says 'No'
With the internet abuzz with allegations against the Republican front runner, Belmont Patch asked the expert, Town Clerk Ellen Cushman. Her answer: Romney's a resident. And the state backs her.
For the past two days, the internet has been abuzz with the latest political scandal, although this one has nothing to do with twitter photos or sexual shenanigans.
And the center of this brewing controversy is ... here.
Did longtime Belmont resident and Republican frontrunner Mitt Romney commit the serious crime of voter fraud – that could result in a five year prison sentence –when in January 2010 he strode up the steps to the second floor of Town Hall to vote in Precinct 2?
The story, which has been on the 'net for less than 72 hours, has exploded over the Web. A google search – which had become the modern de facto gauge of popularity – finds more than one million hits when searching for the key words Romney, voter, fraud.
Yesterday, June 13, MSNBC host Rachel Maddow spent a portion of her opinion program citing the allegations as did numerous media publications in primary states, in magazines such as New York and mentioned on the Huffington Post (editor's note: the Patch network of hyperlocal sites is part of the Huffington Post Media Group).
The allegations against the South Cottage Road resident emerged this week in an article on the Mother Jones magazine website.
In a story written by staff reporter Stephanie Mencimer, Fred Karger – a person who says he is also running for president – said he filed a formal complaint with the Elections Division of the Secretary of State's Office claiming that Romney was not a Massachusetts or Belmont resident when he slide this paper ballot into the scanning machine during the election for US Senator which Scott Brown won.
Karger claimed to Mother Jones that Romney no longer qualifies as a Belmont resident since he has moved several times since failing to win the Republican nomination in the summer of 2008 especially since he sold his long-time Marsh Street home in April 2009 .
Karger said since Ronmey spent a great deal of time in his other homes in La Jolla, California and on Lake Winnipesaukee in New Hampshire, he no longer could claim that his primary residency was Belmont despite registering to vote using his son's Greensbrook Way address.
Karger, which Mother Jones dubbed an expert in performing "opposition research" for Republican candidates, did not believe that Romney was actually living "in his son's basement" nor living in a newly constructed townhouse he bought in June 2010 that Mencimer noted is located on "the grounds of the McLean Mental Hospital."
Mencimer wrote that Karger ventured to Belmont to talk to residents, store owners – including the town's "fish monger" – and members of the Church of the Latter Days Saint's community which the Romney's have been part of the leadership since arriving in Belmont in the early 1970s, all who have said that Romney has not been part of life in Belmont for years.
Talk to the Clerk
Yet the one person that Krager, Mencimer and the other publications and shows that have spotlighted the story did not contact was the Belmont town official who could have answered all their questions.
And Ellen Cushman, Belmont's town clerk and person responsible for voter registration, said that Romney is not only a registered voter and resident of the town since 1972, he actually has been one of the town's most active voters since 1976.
"If everyone was as dedicated as he has been, we'd have a far more involved electorate," said Cushman.
In fact, the last election he missed was a town election in April 2010 when his absentee ballot arrived late.
"And that was the one I was elected as town clerk," joked Cushman.
Since she has been expecting and has received numerous requests for information on Romney's residency, Cushman quickly produced two signed letters from Romney indicating he was changing his Belmont voting address from Marsh Street to Greenbrook Way in May 2009 and then to his present home on South Cottage Road.
See the letters as PDFs on this website.
"Since he meets all the requirements to vote in the country – he's over 18, an American citizen and a resident of the town – he is and has been registered to vote in Belmont," she said.
Cushman noted that as long as Romney isn't trespassing in someone's home and hasn't requested to become a resident of another town anywhere else in the country, he is considered a resident of Belmont.
"Where his residency is"
"And since he is an active voter, he proves that this is where his residency is," said Cushman.
Nor does it appear Romney has attempted to change his official residency since 2008. According to Rosemary Norling at the San Diego County Registrar of Voters, Romney is not and never has been a registered voter in San Diego County. Romney owns at $12 million home in the tony La Jolla neighborhood of San Diego.
While Ronmey is reported to spend considerable time in his other homes and traveling, that is not unusual for many fellow Belmont residents, said Cushman.
"We have quite a number of 'snow birds' who live half the year in Florida or down South and there are residents who use the town as a home-base since they are traveling on business for most of the year," said Cushman.
In fact, many older resident will pick up absentee ballots before heading South so they can vote in Belmont elections, said Cushman.
And the Secretary of the Commonwealth is not only backing Cushman in her ruling that Romney is a valid resident and voter in Belmont but throws a large bucket of ice water on Krager's claims.
"(Krager) sent us and the Department of Revenue, for some reason, only a letter asking us to conduct an investigation," said Brian McNiff, spokesman for Secretary of State William Galvin, then adding, "There will be no investigation."
"The time to challenge a person's residency is before the election, not after," said McNiff.
And McNiff added that it is the responsibility of the town's Registrars of Voters to determine if a person can register to vote in Belmont, a board which Cushman is a member.
"Mr. Romney has declared that Belmont has been his hometown and continues to be so," said Cushman.
"And why should we dispute that?"
James Baer
9:31 pm on Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Fantastic reporting. Mitt Romney is the biggest flip flopper in history. He should be examined for voter fraud. If Joe Public had done this, surely an investigation would be well underway. By the way, the Belmont Patch was prominently featured on the Rachel Maddow Show tonight.
Franklin Tucker
10:46 pm on Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Thanks, James. I would catch TRMS but the Bruins have won the Stanley Cup!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
John Barker
9:38 pm on Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Congrats on this story. As a fellow Patcher, I was excited to see this on national TV. Sorry for adding to your email but I couldn't resist myself.
Daniel Peterson
10:49 pm on Wednesday, June 15, 2011
What silliness. Fred Karger has been on a vendetta against the Mormons for several years, and now he's focused on the Mormon Mitt Romney. Pathetic.
Victoria Siegel
11:38 pm on Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Good work Patch!
Right Speak
10:31 am on Thursday, June 16, 2011
This article should put to rest once and for all that Mitt Romney is not a resident. If Uncle Sam says he is, then HE IS!
Romney in 2012!
James Baer
11:13 am on Thursday, June 16, 2011
Pathetic heh? If the guy lives in California, or somewhere? then if he votes in Massachusetts, he's committed voter fraud. Plain and simple. Say Gov. Romney, where do you really live? In the unfinished basement of your son's home in Belmont? Lets get this right, once and for all.
Franklin Tucker
11:49 am on Thursday, June 16, 2011
Dear Mr. Baer:
I would suggest you view the pdf file which Romney notified the Belmont Town Clerk, Ellen Cushman (yes, she has a name, Ms. Maddow) that he was changing his voting address on the two occasions he moved which he is required to do under state law. He used his son's address (or as Ms. Maddow noted nearing a dozen times, "living in his son's unfinished basement") which under long standing Massachusetts law (and thus Belmont bylaws) he is allowed to do since it appears (Romney has not commented on this allegation of voter fraud) he wanted to keep his legal residency in the town that he first come to in 1972 where he has family and friends.
Yes, Romney does live in California and New Hampshire during the year - in our article we also note that he never attempted to take up residency in La Jolla, California (really, it's San Diego) - but that doesn't make him a resident of those locations just as the large number of Belmont 'snow birds' - usually retired residents - who live in Florida/South Carolina during the winter months are residents of those states.
I would also note that the Massachusetts Secretary of State, the bluest of blue dog Democrat, William Galvin, has decided to dismiss the allegations as a nuisance. No one can call Galvin a Romney lackey unless they are prepared to get a call from the Secretary (which can be a scary call to take, as I well know!)
Thanks for the comments.
Mike
5:36 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012
No, not plain and simple. He has multiple homes and may not even fit residency requirements in many states. So does that mean he can't vote? Of course not. He votes in the place where he has for 40 years, and still has family there. So? He is not registered elsewhere to vote. If he ever settles on another spot, then he can change it.
If his registration is valid, he did not commit Voter Fraud. Period. He would need to commit Voter Registration Fraud first. But the Town Clerk accepted it, so it is legal. Can someone challenge his right to vote? Yes, and if he is then removed form the Registrar, he can't Vote their again. But his past votes still count, and no crime was committed.
And for the record, I can't stand Romney, but there is no case here. Tens of thousands of snowbirds do this (live elsewhere while voting in their hometown). The Clerks in all those places have no problem with it. It is legal.
If he registers in another District and votes, THEN he has committed Voter Fraud. You have a Right to vote, but once.
Lori*
1:05 pm on Thursday, June 16, 2011
Karger is inept. Just another community organizer. Different community but same failed results. Best of luck chasing those rainbows Karger.
Liann
3:39 pm on Friday, June 17, 2011
It is NOT about voter fraud. It is about TAX FRAUD. Massachusetts has very high state income taxes, New Hampshire has none. He was registered to vote in MA, not NH, so where did he pay his state taxes? Either he paid his taxes where he votes or he didn't. It is either TAX FRAUD or VOTER FRAUD, or it isn't. Don't give him time to pay late fees and whitewash over it, like he did when he claimed both Utah and MA as home for the Winter Olympics -- make him show his state tax return for Massachusetts NOW!